UNDIP Physics Department holds Manuscript Clinic for Postgraduate Students, Pairs Writing Tips with AI Guidance

SEMARANG — The physics department at Universitas Diponegoro’s Faculty of Science and Mathematics held a manuscript clinic Wednesday for its master’s students, focused on journal writing and how to use AI tools responsibly during the drafting process.

The two-hour session, called Klinik Manuskrip, ran from 1 to 3 p.m. in a fourth-floor room on campus. Dr. Aji Setiawan, S.Kom., MMSI, a lecturer at Universitas Darma Persada, led the clinic under the theme “Unlock Your Creative Vision.”

The agenda covered four areas: writing technique, what the organizers called “secrets” of journal writing, general tips and tricks, and one-on-one mentoring for students working on manuscripts.

Setiawan walked students through the structure most journals expect: introduction, methods, results, and discussion, followed by a conclusion that states the finding plainly rather than restating the abstract. He also addressed a problem common to physics manuscripts specifically — figures and data tables that don’t match the journal’s formatting requirements, which is one of the more frequent reasons editors send papers back before they even reach peer review.

On journal selection, the session covered how to check a journal’s scope and indexing status before submitting, and how to spot predatory journals that charge publication fees without real peer review. Students also went over citation management tools such as Mendeley and Zotero, and how to run a plagiarism check with Turnitin before submission.

A portion of the clinic dealt with AI writing tools directly. Setiawan discussed where tools like ChatGPT and Claude can help — drafting an outline, tightening grammar, summarizing background literature — and where they can cause problems. AI models can generate citations that don’t exist or misstate a paper’s findings, so any AI-assisted draft needs a full fact-check against the original sources before submission. He also pointed out that many journals now require authors to disclose AI use in their methods or acknowledgments section, and that failing to disclose it can get a manuscript rejected outright.

The mentoring segment gave students time to bring their own drafts and get feedback one-on-one, including on how to respond to reviewer comments during revision — a step several attendees said they found harder than writing the first draft.

Journal publication is often a graduation requirement for master’s students in Indonesia, which is part of why the physics department has kept running these clinics. The department promotes them through its Instagram account, @fiskundip, and its website, fisika.undip.ac.id.